Renovation projects often expose structural steel without CMTRs. This guide covers how AWS D1.1:2025 handles unknown-grade base metal — from identification testing to EOR approval to documentation requirements.
Renovation and retrofit projects present a problem that never comes up on new construction: what is this steel? Columns that went up in the 1950s. Lintels embedded in a 1970s concrete addition. Mezzanine framing added by an unknown contractor before the shop kept digital records. The structural drawings may be lost, the mill certs were never retained, and the beam itself carries no legible heat number stamp.
The welder cannot proceed until the base metal has a known specification — or until an engineer has formally addressed the unknown. This article explains how AWS D1.1:2025 structures that decision and what your QC system must document before the first arc is struck.
Why Base Metal Identity Matters Under AWS D1.1:2025
AWS D1.1:2025 Clause 5 governs base metals for structural welding. For a prequalified WPS, the base metal must match one of the specifications listed in Table 5.6, the prequalified base metal table. That table groups carbon and low-alloy structural steels — ASTM A36, A572 Gr 50, A992, A500 Grade C, and others — into compatibility groups (Group I through Group IV) based on chemistry and strength level.
If your steel is not in Table 5.6, or cannot be verified as one of those specifications, a prequalified WPS cannot be used. The two code-compliant paths are:
Identify the steel through testing and have the EOR assign it to the nearest Table 5.6 classification.
Qualify by test — run a PQR on the actual base metal under Clause 6, treating the material as an unlisted steel.
Neither path is a "just weld it" option. Both require engineering judgment and project documentation before welding starts.
Step One: Search for Original Documentation
The first step is not testing — it is paperwork. Contact the building owner, original contractor, or relevant state archive for:
Original structural drawings stamped by the engineer of record
Construction specifications from the original project package
Any historical CMTRs or heat numbers retained by the original fabricator or structural steel erector
Buildings constructed from the 1940s through the 1990s were typically designed to ASTM A36 (or its predecessor ASTM A7 for pre-1960s work). Many facility owners, school districts, and state agencies maintain as-built records in document rooms or document management systems. Two hours of archive research beats a spectrometer test.
Where the structural drawings survive, they usually specify the base metal. The notation "ALL STRUCTURAL STEEL ASTM A36 UNLESS NOTED" appears on thousands of shop drawing packages from that era. That is not a CMTR, but it establishes the specification and allows a prequalified WPS to proceed with the EOR's written acknowledgment.
Identify the Steel Through Field or Laboratory Testing
When documentation is exhausted, testing establishes the chemistry.
Heat Number Tracing
Wide-flange and other rolled shapes are typically stamped at the web with the heat number and mill information at rolling intervals. A heat number can be traced to the original CMTR through the steel mill's records department or through a steel service center's archive. This is worth pursuing for critical members — many mills retain heat records for decades.
Portable Chemistry Testing
Portable X-ray fluorescence (pXRF) or optical emission spectroscopy (OES) reads carbon, manganese, silicon, phosphorus, sulfur, and alloying elements from a prepared surface in under a minute. Accuracy is sufficient for calculating carbon equivalent and placing the steel in the right Table 5.6 group. Testing firms offer on-site service for occupied buildings.
Laboratory wet chemistry analysis is the most precise method. A sample is drilled or cut from the base metal and analyzed by an accredited laboratory. Required when the pXRF result is borderline between groups or when the EOR requires certified documentation.
Hardness Testing
Rockwell B or Vickers hardness on a ground surface cross-checks yield strength range. HRB readings in the range of 70–85 are consistent with A36-class carbon steel; readings above HRB 90 suggest a higher-strength or alloy grade. Hardness alone cannot certify a base metal specification, but it flags when more precise chemistry testing is warranted.
From Chemistry to Preheat: Using Annex B
Once chemistry is in hand, the carbon equivalent calculation from AWS D1.1:2025 Annex B replaces conservative guesswork with a rational preheat determination. Annex B provides the IIW formula:
CE = C + Mn/6 + (Cr + Mo + V)/5 + (Ni + Cu)/15
For carbon-manganese steels typical of older structural construction, this calculation places most material at CE between 0.35 and 0.45. At that CE range and typical structural plate thicknesses, AWS D1.1:2025 Table 5.11 minimum preheat requirements will usually be met at ambient shop temperature or with modest preheat of 50–70°F above ambient — confirm from the actual chemistry result, do not assume.
Rule library based on AWS D1.1:2025; verify against your governing edition.
If chemistry testing cannot be arranged before the schedule requires welding, a conservative engineering floor of 150°F (65°C) is a defensible interim position for carbon structural steel. This is not a code-mandated number — it is an engineering risk-management choice that the EOR must approve and document in writing.
Filler Metal Selection for Unknown-Grade Carbon Steel
For the carbon structural steels most commonly encountered in renovation projects — ASTM A36, A529, early A572 — the appropriate low-hydrogen filler metals are:
FCAW-G: AWS A5.20 E71T-1C, E71T-9C, or A5.36 E71T1-C1A0 class (70 ksi, gas-shielded)
SAW: AWS A5.17 EM12K or EM13K with matching F7-class flux
Avoid 80 ksi or higher filler metals until the base metal classification is confirmed. Overmatching filler on unknown-grade carbon steel increases hydrogen cracking risk and adds no benefit to joint performance. The 70 ksi filler classification is a nonessential variable under Table 6.6 for most processes, so a PQR run on the unknown base metal with a 70 ksi filler will cover future work with the same filler class without requalification.
When the EOR Requires a PQR on the Actual Material
For structurally critical scope — moment frame connections, demand-critical welds under AWS D1.8, fracture-critical members — the EOR may require a PQR on the actual recovered base metal rather than accepting classification by CE calculation. This is especially appropriate for:
Pre-1960s material that may contain free-machining additives (sulfur, lead) beyond current limits
Material showing visible laminations or unusual behavior during air carbon arc gouging
Welds where CVN toughness requirements are invoked under Table 6.8 supplementary essential variables
A PQR on the actual steel costs more than chemical classification, but it provides direct mechanical test evidence that the procedure produces acceptable properties in the specific material. For connections where failure consequences are severe, that test evidence is worth having.
QC File Documentation Before Welding Starts
Your project file must contain the following before work proceeds on unidentified steel:
EOR written approval — classifying the steel to a Table 5.6 specification or authorizing the PQR route. Without this, do not weld.
Testing report — pXRF, OES, or laboratory chemistry with the sample location, date, and testing laboratory identification.
CE calculation — formula used, input values from the chemistry report, and resulting preheat determination.
Preheat rationale — the selected temperature, referencing Table 5.11 or the Annex B calculation, with the EOR's approval signature.
Filler metal selection justification — why the selected filler classification was appropriate for the base metal's classification.
WPS reference — the specific procedure used, whether prequalified (following EOR classification) or qualified by test.
This documentation package protects the fabricator, the EOR, and the building owner if the weld is inspected or litigated years later.
For more context on the base metal framework in D1.1 and related topics:
Managing WPS qualification and base metal documentation across renovation and retrofit projects is exactly what WPS Welding's procedure management platform is built for — organized, audit-ready, with the edition disclaimers baked in.
FAQ
Frequently asked.
Can I weld on structural steel without a certified mill test report under AWS D1.1:2025?
AWS D1.1:2025 requires base metal to be identified to a specific ASTM specification or approved equivalent before a prequalified WPS can be used. Without a CMTR or other documentation, the engineer of record must authorize a path forward — either classifying the steel through chemical testing or requiring a PQR on the actual material. No provision allows welding on completely unidentified steel without engineering approval.
What tests can identify unknown structural steel for welding qualification purposes?
Portable X-ray fluorescence (pXRF) spectrometry or optical emission spectroscopy (OES) determines full chemistry so the carbon equivalent can be calculated. Rockwell or Vickers hardness testing cross-checks the yield strength range. Combined with original construction drawings or heat number tracing, these tests give the EOR enough data to classify the steel against the prequalified base metal table or specify a PQR on the actual material.
What filler metal should I use when the base metal chemistry is unknown?
The conservative choice is a 70 ksi class filler — AWS A5.1 E7018 for SMAW or AWS A5.20 E71T-1C for FCAW-G. These fillers match the minimum expected yield of most structural carbon steels (A36, A529, early A572) without overmatching to the point of increasing hydrogen cracking risk. Avoid 80 ksi or higher classifications until the base metal is positively identified.
What preheat applies to steel of unknown grade?
Without a known carbon equivalent, apply the most conservative category from AWS D1.1:2025 Table 5.11 for the process and thickness combination, or use an Annex B CE calculation once field chemistry is obtained. Many shops conservatively adopt 150°F (65°C) as a floor temperature for unidentified steel — not a code-mandated number, but a defensible engineering floor that the EOR should approve and document.