The end of the year is the right time for a structural fab shop's CWI or QC manager to pull out the welding procedure library and confirm it still matches reality. Projects drift: new processes get added to the shop floor, filler metals get substituted mid-run, welders change, and sometimes an edition transition or a new code cycle makes existing procedure documentation incomplete. An annual WPS library review is the systematic check that keeps an AISC-certified shop audit-ready and prevents production surprises when a third-party CWI or owner's inspector arrives on-site.
This checklist walks through the key review areas. It is structured for shops operating under AWS D1.1:2025 as the primary code, though the approach applies equally to shops carrying ASME IX, AWS D1.6, or D1.5 qualifications alongside their D1.1 library.
1. Edition Currency Check
Goal: Confirm every active WPS references the edition of AWS D1.1 in force for current and upcoming contracts.
AWS D1.1:2025 is the current ANSI-approved edition. Projects contracted under D1.1:2020 are still active in many shops, and the governing edition is what the contract specifies—not necessarily the latest published version. However, if your shop has adopted 2025 as the in-house standard, all new WPS documents should reference it.
Review tasks:
- Pull every active WPS and confirm the edition reference in the qualification basis or header block.
- For WPS documents marked "Prequalified per AWS D1.1:2020 Clause 5," verify that the essential variable rules and prequalified joint geometry are still valid under 2025 if the shop has transitioned.
- Note any contracts specifically calling out 2020 or earlier—those WPS documents do not need to change for those jobs, but the distinction should be documented.
The 2025 vs. 2020 essential variable renumbering is the main structural change relevant to your review: essential variables for SMAW/GMAW/FCAW/GTAW/SAW are now Table 6.6 (was Table 6.5 in 2020). CVN supplementary essential variables are Table 6.8 (was Table 6.7 in 2020). If your WPS documents cite table numbers, verify they match the edition claimed.
Rule library based on AWS D1.1:2025; verify against your governing edition.
2. WPS Coverage vs. Production Scope
Goal: Confirm every weld type currently made in production is covered by an active, qualified WPS.
This is the most common audit failure: the shop has a solid library for beam-column connections, but it added a product line—mezzanine platforms, handrail frames, stair assemblies, equipment pads, cable tray supports—and no one checked whether the existing WPS covers those weld configurations.
Review tasks:
- Pull your current production scope from the estimating or project list. List every product type and its weld joint configurations (fillet, PJP, CJP groove; positions; base metals).
- Compare against the WPS library. For each product, identify the WPS number intended to cover it.
- Flag any product or weld type with no clear WPS coverage. These need either a new WPS or a scope extension of an existing one before production begins.
- Review for base metal traceability: does each WPS cover the actual ASTM designations purchased? A36 and A992 are the most common, but if the shop has taken delivery of A529 Grade 55, A500 Grade C, or other metals not in the original WPS scope, check coverage.
3. Essential Variable Traceability to PQR
Goal: Confirm each tested WPS (Clause 6) traces to a valid PQR with no undocumented essential variable departures.
This is the technical core of the WPS library review. For every WPS developed by test (not prequalified), the PQR on file must reflect the actual test conditions, and the WPS must stay within the essential variable ranges that the PQR supports.
Review tasks:
- Pull each Clause 6 WPS and its supporting PQR(s). Confirm the PQR number(s) are listed on the WPS.
- For each PQR, confirm the original test records are on file: test coupon dimensions, test method (tensile, guided bend, CVN if required), test lab report, and witness certification (if required by the contract or owner spec).
- For each essential variable in AWS D1.1:2025 Table 6.6, compare the WPS production parameter range against the PQR test parameters:
- Filler metal classification: WPS must match PQR classification (or be within the allowed substitution range per Clause 6)
- Base metal group: WPS base metal must be within the group qualification range established by the PQR
- Thickness range: WPS production thickness must fall within the PQR qualification range per Clause 6.8 (qualified range is typically 1× to 2× the PQR test plate thickness for groove welds)
- Heat input range: qualified range from PQR with applicable allowable variation
- Position: WPS position must be within the PQR qualification
- If any WPS production parameter falls outside the PQR support range, that is a nonconformance. Issue an NCR and determine the corrective path: either run a new PQR test, adjust the WPS production range back inside qualification, or find a prequalified route if applicable.
4. PQR Physical Test Record Completeness
Goal: Confirm PQR test records satisfy D1.1 documentation requirements and would survive third-party scrutiny.
Review tasks:
- Verify each PQR has a completed AWS D1.1 PQR form (or equivalent in Annex J format) with all required fields: base metal specification, heat/lot number, filler metal specification and classification, preheat/interpass temperatures, actual measured amperage/voltage/travel speed, and test results.
- Confirm test lab reports are attached: tensile test load/area/location of fracture, guided bend test photo or description of results, CVN test results if D1.8 demand-critical or supplementary essential variables apply.
- If a PQR was witnessed, the witness certification or statement should be on file. Some owner specifications and AISC Chapter 4 quality programs require witnessed PQRs.
- Review for PQR expiration concerns: D1.1 does not expire a PQR, but if the original test plates or samples are needed for follow-up testing (retests, additional bend specimens), their retention should be verified per your QC manual.