7 min read

New Structural Fab Shop: First PQR Timeline and Planning

A new structural fabricator's guide to qualifying the first welding procedure record under AWS D1.1 — which processes to test first, testing lab selection, timeline expectations, and the prequalified WPS alternative.

New to procedures? Start with WPS welding: what a welding procedure specification is, with a filled-in example.

Every Qualified Shop Started Somewhere

Every AISC-certified structural fabricator with a qualified welding program started at the same place: no procedures, no test records, and a first project that required them. Getting from zero to a defensible, audit-ready WPS library under AWS D1.1 takes planning — and understanding the two available paths.

The good news is that AWS D1.1 offers a shortcut for many common structural joints: prequalified WPS, requiring no testing at all. The harder path — running qualification test plates and generating PQRs — is necessary when that shortcut isn't available. Knowing which path fits which situation, and how to execute the testing path efficiently, is the foundation of any new welding program.

Path 1: Start with Prequalified WPS (No PQR Required)

AWS D1.1 Clause 5 allows a fabricator to write and use a WPS without any PQR testing, provided all of the following conditions are met:

  • The welding process is one of the listed prequalified processes: SMAW, FCAW-G, SAW, GMAW (spray or globular transfer), or GTAW.
  • The base metal is listed in Table 5.6 (prequalified base metal groups).
  • The joint design matches one of the prequalified joint geometries described in Clause 5 Figures 5.1, 5.2, and 5.3.
  • All process parameters stay within the Clause 5 limits, including preheat per Table 5.11 and filler metal per the prequalified filler metal lists.

Rule library based on AWS D1.1:2025; verify against your governing edition.

For a new shop taking on a first structural project — beams, columns, and standard connections using A36, A572, or A992 steel with SMAW or FCAW-G — prequalified WPS is likely available and provides a legal, code-compliant shortcut. The WPS can be written in-house, reviewed and signed by an employed CWI or Responsible Welding Engineer, and used immediately.

The limitation of prequalified WPS is its rigidity. Clause 5 permits a narrower range of heat inputs, joint geometries, and process parameters than a tested WPS. When a job requires something outside those limits — higher heat input, unlisted base metals, special joint geometries, or processes like GMAW short-circuit transfer — a prequalified WPS cannot be written, and testing is required. See Prequalified vs. Qualified-by-Test WPS Under AWS D1.1 for a detailed comparison of scope limits.

Path 2: Running the First PQR

When prequalified WPS cannot cover the work, or when the shop needs tested procedures for broader flexibility, the PQR process begins. This is not as daunting as it sounds, but it requires coordination between the shop, an accredited testing lab, and a CWI witness.

Select the Right Testing Laboratory

The laboratory performing destructive mechanical testing must be capable of running the required specimens under ASTM testing standards. For AWS D1.1 PQR testing, the typical test coupon requires:

  • Reduced-section tensile specimens
  • Face-bend and root-bend specimens (or side-bend for material over 1-1/2 in [38 mm])
  • Macro cross-section examination for fillet welds

For CJP groove weld PQR tests with CVN supplementary essential variables under AWS D1.1 Table 6.8, Charpy V-notch specimens are also required. See CVN Supplementary Essential Variables per AWS D1.1 Table 6.8 for details.

Look for labs with AWS Accredited Testing Laboratory (ATL) status or AISC-recognized testing capability. Some independent inspection agencies offer PQR testing services including coupon welding, witnessing, and lab coordination as a package. For first-time shops, this turnkey option can simplify the process significantly. See PQR Test Laboratory Selection Under AWS D1.1 for evaluation criteria.

Which Test Plates to Run First

For a general structural fab shop, the highest return on the first PQR test investment comes from procedures that qualify the widest range of production work:

FCAW-G 3G (vertical up) groove weld: A 3G test plate on the low end of practical thickness range qualifies 1G (flat) and 2G (horizontal) positions as well, and qualifies an unlimited thickness range on the upward side. FCAW-G is the dominant process in structural shops — this PQR covers the majority of groove welds you will encounter.

SMAW 3G groove weld: Covers flat, horizontal, and vertical for stick electrode. Many projects still specify SMAW for certain joint types, and the stick process is the standard fallback when FCAW-G is impractical.

FCAW-G fillet weld: A separate PQR for fillet welds is not always required — a groove weld PQR qualifies fillet welds of the same process — but verifying fillet performance explicitly is good QC practice when fillet welds make up the bulk of a shop's production.

A 2G test plate (horizontal position) separately qualifies only flat and horizontal. For shops that want overhead (4G) coverage, a 4G or 3G+4G test plate extends position qualification. However, 3G alone is typically sufficient for most structural fab shop production, since overhead welding is relatively rare in shop fabrication.

PQR Test Plate Variables Must Match Production Intent

The test plate must be welded under the same essential variables that production welding will use. Under AWS D1.1:2025 Table 6.6, essential variables for SMAW, FCAW-G, GMAW, and GTAW include process, electrode classification, current type/polarity, position, and base metal group, among others. If the production WPS will use E71T-1M-H8 FCAW-G wire, the PQR test plate should be welded with that wire or its equivalent to avoid requalification later.

For a full breakdown of Table 6.6 essential variables and what changes trigger requalification, see FCAW-G Essential Variables per AWS D1.1 Table 6.6.

Who Witnesses the Test Plate Welding

A CWI must witness the test plate welding and document the actual parameters used. This is not a mere observation — the witness records voltage, amperage, travel speed, electrode classification, heat number, preheat temperature, interpass temperature, and other essential variables as the weld is made. These recorded values become the PQR's essential variable list.

The CWI may be the fabricator's own staff, an owner's representative, or a third-party inspector. Some projects or owners require independent witness; AWS D1.1 itself does not mandate it. See PQR Witness Requirements Under AWS D1.1 for the documentation requirements.

Timeline from Test Plate to Approved WPS

A realistic timeline for a first PQR program:

Phase Duration
Lab selection and test plate planning 1–2 weeks
Test plate welding (shop floor) 1 day
Lab specimen cutting, prep, and testing 1–2 weeks
Test report delivery and CWI review 3–5 days
WPS writing, review, and sign-off 1 week
Total (typical) 4–7 weeks

Rush lab services compress the testing phase but increase cost. For projects with tight schedules, pre-ordering the test plates and scheduling the lab before welding begins avoids waiting for open lab slots.

Plan to run test plates at least six weeks before the first production use of the resulting WPS. That buffer absorbs a failed test (which requires a retest plate and additional lab time) without delaying the project.

What to Do When Tests Fail

A failed PQR mechanical test is not a career-ending event — it is information. Under AWS D1.1, most failed tests allow retesting: two additional specimens of the failed type may be tested. If both pass, the original failure may be treated as anomalous and the PQR may proceed. If additional failures occur, the procedure parameters must be investigated and revised before a new test plate is welded.

Common failure modes and their causes:

  • Tensile failure in the HAZ: may indicate excessive heat input, insufficient preheat, or base metal issues.
  • Bend test cracks: often caused by lack of fusion from insufficient heat, excessive travel speed, or poor joint geometry setup.
  • CVN impact failures: heat input too high (coarse HAZ grain), preheat too low for the alloy content, or electrode lot with inadequate impact performance at the test temperature.

Document everything about the failure, correct the variable, and re-weld. The retest record should cross-reference the original test.

See Failed PQR Mechanical Test Retesting Under AWS D1.1 for the specific retest provisions.

Building Toward AISC Certification

For shops pursuing AISC fabricator certification, qualified welding procedures are a prerequisite — auditors verify that the WPS library covers the work being performed and that each WPS is supported by a compliant PQR or falls within prequalified Clause 5 scope. Starting the PQR program before the certification application, rather than scrambling during the audit, positions the shop for a clean first audit.

The certification audit reviews not just whether procedures are qualified, but whether the shop has a welding program: a QC manual, documented CWI involvement, welder qualification records, and production inspection records tied back to qualified procedures. The PQR library is the foundation, but the full program architecture matters.

For shops managing WPS libraries, PQR records, and welder qualifications across multiple projects, wpswelding.com/pricing offers tools to track procedure coverage, qualification ranges, and audit-ready records in one platform.

Summary

A new structural fabricator has two paths to qualified welding procedures: prequalified WPS (no testing, narrower scope) and tested WPS backed by PQR (testing required, broader flexibility). Start with prequalified WPS where it fits, run your first test plates strategically to maximize coverage, build in six weeks of schedule buffer before first production use, and document everything through a CWI-witnessed process. That foundation supports AISC certification, owner audits, and the credibility that structural clients expect from a shop asking them to trust their welds.

FAQ

Frequently asked.

Can a new fab shop use prequalified WPS to avoid running PQR tests?
Yes. AWS D1.1 Clause 5 allows prequalified WPS without PQR testing for listed processes (SMAW, FCAW-G, SAW, GMAW spray/globular, GTAW) with listed base metals from Table 5.6, using prequalified joint designs and within all Clause 5 constraints. This is the fastest path to production for a new shop taking on its first structural project.
What processes should a new structural fab shop qualify first with a PQR?
FCAW-G and SMAW cover the broadest range of structural connections and positions at the lowest equipment cost. SAW adds value for shops doing significant plate work, built-up girders, or column fabrication. For most general structural work, two or three well-chosen PQRs supporting FCAW-G and SMAW will cover the majority of job requirements.
How long does a full PQR test take from test plate to approved WPS?
Typically 3–6 weeks total: test plate welding and destructive cutting (1 day), lab specimen preparation and mechanical testing (1–2 weeks), test report delivery and CWI review (1 week), WPS completion and approval sign-off (1 week). Rush lab services can compress the lab phase but increase cost.
Does the CWI who witnesses the PQR test plate weld have to be independent?
No. Under AWS D1.1, the CWI who witnesses the PQR test plate welding may be the fabricator's own employed CWI, an owner's representative, or an independent inspection agency. Independence is not required by the code, but some owner specifications or AISC certification programs may require a third-party witness.

More from the blog