When Charpy Testing Enters the WPS Qualification
Standard AWS D1.1 WPS qualification under Clause 6 requires tensile and guided-bend tests. Charpy V-notch (CVN) impact testing is not part of the base qualification for most structural applications — it enters the PQR only when the contract documents, the engineer of record's specification, or a referenced design standard explicitly requires toughness qualification.
The applications that commonly trigger CVN PQR testing in structural steel work:
- Cold-service structures (minimum service temperature below 32°F / 0°C)
- Seismic demand-critical welds per AISC 341 / AWS D1.8
- Fracture-critical member connections under owner or AISC specification
- Bridges designed to AWS D1.5 (which has its own CVN requirements)
When CVN is invoked, the PQR test plate must produce Charpy specimens at specified locations, at a specified test temperature, meeting minimum absorbed energy and lateral expansion requirements. Critically, once CVN qualification is part of the PQR, the supplementary essential variables in AWS D1.1:2025 Table 6.8 become binding — changes to those variables require requalification whether or not the base essential variables in Table 6.6 are affected.
Rule library based on AWS D1.1:2025; verify against your governing edition (the AHJ or contract may specify 2020 or earlier).
PQR Test Plate Layout for CVN Specimens
The PQR test coupon for groove welds is a multi-pass weld plate that serves as the source for all mechanical test specimens. When CVN is required, the test plan allocates locations in the coupon for impact specimens in addition to the standard tensile and bend specimens.
Charpy V-notch specimens (ASTM A370, 10mm × 10mm standard size or sub-size) are machined perpendicular to the weld, with the notch oriented to sample either:
- Weld metal — notch located within the deposited weld metal, away from the fusion line
- Heat-affected zone (HAZ) — notch located at the fusion line, 1 mm from fusion line, 2 mm from fusion line, or 5 mm from fusion line, as specified
The distinction matters because weld metal CVN performance and HAZ CVN performance can differ substantially for the same procedure. High-heat-input SAW procedures that produce excellent weld metal toughness can produce coarse-grained HAZ regions with significantly lower impact energy. The test plan must specify which locations are tested for the application.
For seismic demand-critical welds per AISC 341, CVN requirements typically apply to the weld metal specifically, reflecting the fracture mechanics of cyclically loaded connections. The specification for those applications sets both the notch location and the minimum energy at the specified test temperature.
How Many Specimens and Where
AWS D1.1 itself does not prescribe a specific Charpy specimen count per PQR. When CVN is required, the test plan is either:
- Specified by the contract documents or project specification
- Derived from AISC 341 Appendix W requirements for seismic procedures
- Set by the testing laboratory in consultation with the EOR based on the application
A commonly used test matrix for structural cold-service PQR qualification:
- Three specimens — weld metal centerline
- Three specimens — fusion line (HAZ)
- Three specimens — 1 mm from fusion line (HAZ, CGHAZ if thermally severe)
The three-specimen set at each location provides a set average. Single-specimen outliers that fall below the specified minimum are evaluated against the set: typically, no more than one specimen may fall below the minimum, and no specimen may fall below 2/3 of the minimum, for the set to pass. The governing specification defines the acceptance criterion; the test plan should reference it explicitly rather than leaving it to the lab's interpretation.
Specimen thickness: when plate thickness is insufficient for a full 10mm × 10mm Charpy bar (generally plates thinner than 11 mm), sub-size specimens (7.5 mm × 10 mm, 5 mm × 10 mm) are permissible per ASTM A370 with adjusted acceptance criteria. The PQR must record the specimen dimensions so the qualification coverage can be correctly evaluated.
Test Temperature and Shift
CVN specimens are tested at the temperature specified by the contract or design standard, not at room temperature. The test temperature should reflect the minimum anticipated service temperature for the structure, sometimes adjusted by a ductile-to-brittle transition margin.
AWS D1.5 (bridge welding) has explicit CVN temperature and energy requirements. AISC 341 and AWS D1.8 specify 70°F (21°C) test temperature for demand-critical weld metal CVN as a standard baseline, with the assumption that structural steel fabrication in the US does not typically expose moment frame joints to temperatures below 0°F in service.
For cold-service structures — unheated tanks, offshore platforms in northern climates, arctic exposure — the test temperature may be -40°F (-40°C) or lower. The cryogenic test procedure is conducted per ASTM A370 with specimens submerged in a refrigerated bath and transferred to the anvil within a specified time window. Lab capability to conduct cryogenic Charpy testing is a real constraint: not all accredited labs are equipped for sub-zero work, which affects PQR test laboratory selection.