A SMAW root pass followed by FCAW-G fill and cap is one of the most common hybrid welding sequences in structural steel fabrication. The two-process approach lets welders take advantage of SMAW's positional flexibility and arc control for root pass integrity, then switch to FCAW-G's deposition efficiency for the fill passes that dominate the volume and the schedule.
From a WPS qualification standpoint, combining two processes under one document is straightforward in concept — but it requires careful application of the essential variable tables to each process segment. The most frequent mistake is applying essential variable scope as if the WPS were a single process, when in fact each process section carries its own independent list of changes that trigger requalification.
Rule library based on AWS D1.1:2025; verify against your governing edition.
The Fundamental Rule: One Essential Variable Table Per Process
AWS D1.1:2025 Table 6.6 defines essential variables for five covered processes: SMAW, SAW, GMAW, FCAW, and GTAW. Each process has its own row entries in the table. When a WPS covers multiple processes — SMAW plus FCAW-G, for example — Table 6.6 applies to each process independently.
This means the qualified parameter range for SMAW (electrode classification, current type and polarity, position, preheat) is governed by the SMAW rows in Table 6.6. The qualified parameter range for FCAW-G (wire classification, shielding gas, wire diameter, current range, voltage, interpass temperature) is governed by the FCAW rows. A change that falls within the qualified range for one process has no effect on the essential variable status of the other — they are evaluated in parallel, not jointly.
The practical consequence: when you change an FCAW-G essential variable — say, substituting a different wire classification — you must requalify the WPS for the FCAW-G process. If the SMAW root pass parameters have not changed, the SMAW portion of the WPS remains qualified from the original PQR. You can write a supplemental PQR for the FCAW-G change and update the WPS to reference both PQRs without re-running the mechanical tests on the root pass segment.
What Counts as an Essential Variable for Each Process
For the SMAW root pass under Table 6.6, the most commonly triggered essential variables in structural practice are:
- Change in the AWS A5 filler metal specification (e.g., A5.1 to A5.5)
- Change in electrode classification (e.g., E7018 to E7016) — if the new classification has a different strength level or supplemental designator affecting notch toughness
- Increase in base metal thickness beyond the qualified range (150% of the test plate for groove welds, subject to position and joint type qualifications)
- Change in position to one not qualified on the test plate
- Change in current type or polarity (DCEP to DCEN, or AC)
- Decrease in preheat or interpass temperature below the qualified minimum
For the FCAW-G fill pass segment, the commonly triggered essential variables are:
- Change in the AWS A5 filler metal specification (A5.20 to A5.36, or vice versa) — note that under Table 6.6, the 2025 edition removed A5.36 from the GMAW/FCAW interchangeable group (row 4)
- Change in shielding gas composition or flow rate beyond the qualified range (see shielding gas essential variable documentation)
- Change in wire diameter beyond the qualified range
- Addition or deletion of flux or supplemental backing (groove welds)
- Change in voltage range or WFS range beyond the qualified limits
- Change from flux-cored to metal-cored (FCAW to GMAW classification change)
For CVN-qualified welds, the Table 6.8 supplementary essential variables layer onto both process segments independently. A change in heat input that affects toughness must be evaluated against the CVN test conditions for whichever process segment the change affects. See CVN supplementary essential variables under Table 6.8 for how the supplementary table interacts with the main essential variable scope.
Qualifying the Multi-Process WPS: Test Plate Options
When qualifying a multi-process WPS from scratch, the most efficient approach is a single test plate that uses both processes in sequence — SMAW root, then FCAW-G fill — exactly as the production welds will be made. The test plate assembly simulates the production joint: the root pass opens the groove, the SMAW welds the root, and the FCAW-G fills the remainder.
The mechanical test specimens (tensile, guided bend, macro sections) evaluate the completed weld regardless of how many processes contributed to it. The PQR documents:
- Which process was used for each pass or pass range
- The parameters for each process during the test weld (amperage, voltage, WFS, travel speed, preheat, interpass)
- The test results for the full assembly
Both process sections are then referenced in the WPS as qualified by this single PQR. If the SMAW root parameters are later changed — for example, electrode diameter increased — a supplemental SMAW PQR is needed; the original FCAW-G qualification carries over.
When processes are qualified at different times or from different test programs, the WPS references multiple PQRs. The header of the Annex J WPS form includes a field for supporting PQR numbers — list all PQRs whose essential variable ranges apply to the parameters in this WPS.