Preheat and interpass temperature requirements in a WPS are only as good as the measurement that backs them up. A CWI can sign off on a preheat that was never really at the required minimum if the measurement practice is poor. Understanding which measurement tools work, where to take readings, and how to document results is a core competency for structural welding inspection — not a procedural footnote.
What AWS D1.1:2025 Actually Requires
AWS D1.1:2025 specifies minimum preheat temperatures based on base metal group, thickness, and in some cases the carbon equivalent of the material. These values appear in the preheat tables of the code and are incorporated into the WPS preheat and interpass temperature fields. Rule library based on AWS D1.1:2025; verify against your governing edition.
The code requires that the base metal be at or above the minimum preheat temperature before welding begins. For multi-pass welds, the interpass temperature — the temperature of the previously deposited weld metal and adjacent base metal before the next pass — must not fall below the minimum preheat nor exceed the maximum interpass temperature specified in the WPS.
What the code does not dictate is how you measure these temperatures. The measurement method is left to the contractor and CWI, provided the results are accurate enough to confirm compliance. This is where judgment and practice matter.
Tempilstik (Temperature-Indicating Crayons)
Tempilstik — the common trade name for temperature-indicating crayons — remains the most widely used preheat verification tool on structural job sites. The crayon is formulated to melt at a specific temperature. The CWI marks the base metal approximately 3 inches from the weld joint. If the mark liquefies and smears when the metal reaches the rated temperature, the minimum has been achieved. If the mark stays solid and chalky, the metal has not reached that temperature.
Advantages: Simple, inexpensive, requires no calibration, easily observed at a distance, leaves a visible mark for photographic documentation. Each crayon is single-purpose — a 250°F Tempilstik confirms 250°F and nothing else.
Limitations: Single-point temperature only; to verify 300°F you need a 300°F crayon, not just a 250°F one. The mark can be misleading on very smooth or oily surfaces. The crayon should be applied before heating so the mark is on unpretreated steel.
For routine structural preheat at 50°F, 150°F, 225°F, or 300°F — the most common AWS D1.1 preheat minimums — Tempilstik verification is fast and reliable. Most shops stock a set of crayons covering their typical preheat range.
Contact Pyrometers
A contact pyrometer uses a thermocouple-tipped probe held against the steel surface to measure temperature directly. The instrument displays a digital reading in real time, typically within a few seconds of contact.
Advantages: Gives an exact temperature reading, not just a pass/fail at a set point. Useful when you need to know whether you're at 280°F or 300°F, rather than just confirming you've cleared a minimum. Reusable and can cover any temperature in its range. Newer instruments log readings with timestamps, which is useful for documented inspection records.
Limitations: Requires calibration on a defined schedule (typically per manufacturer recommendations, at minimum annually or after instrument impact). The probe must make firm contact with the steel surface — a poor contact reading can be 20-30°F low. Probe wear affects accuracy over time.
For projects with stringent documentation requirements — AISC Tier 2 special inspection, demand-critical CVN welds, bridge work under D1.5 — a calibrated contact pyrometer gives a defensible recorded temperature rather than a "met/not met" crayon observation.
Infrared Thermometers
Infrared thermometers (also called IR guns or non-contact pyrometers) measure surface temperature by detecting infrared radiation. Point and shoot — no contact required. They are convenient and popular in other industries, but structural welding is a context where their accuracy limitation matters significantly.
Steel's emissivity varies widely depending on surface condition:
- Mill scale: approximately 0.80–0.85
- Polished steel: approximately 0.07–0.20
- Rusted steel: approximately 0.70–0.80
- Steel with intact primer or coating: highly variable
An IR thermometer set for emissivity 0.95 — the standard factory setting — will underread a polished steel surface by 100°F or more at typical preheat temperatures. On structural steel with mixed mill scale and cut surfaces, the error is less dramatic but still significant. A 200°F reading on an IR gun pointed at a clean-cut steel edge could correspond to 250°F actual temperature or 180°F actual temperature depending on surface condition.
Acceptable use conditions: IR thermometers are useful for relative comparisons (is one end of the joint hotter than the other?) and for monitoring heat buildup trends. They can be used for preheat verification when:
- The instrument allows emissivity adjustment and the value has been set appropriately for the actual surface
- The result is cross-checked against a Tempilstik or contact reading during setup to confirm the IR reading is accurate for that surface condition
- The QC plan documents this calibration check
Unless these conditions are met and documented, default to contact methods for preheat and interpass verification.