AISC fabricator certification covers dozens of categories — standard steel structures (STD), seismic (SBM), bridges, and more — but every audit shares one predictable section: the review of welding procedure documentation. The auditor will request your WPS, the PQRs that support them, and your welders' current qualification records. In nearly every initial certification audit and many renewal audits, that documentation review surfaces findings before the auditor has even walked the shop floor.
This article focuses on the WPS, PQR, and WPQ failures most commonly cited in AISC certification audits — not to describe how to cheat an audit, but because fixing these gaps before you request your first audit saves significant time and the cost of a re-audit visit.
What AISC Certification Checks on Welding Documents
AISC fabricator certification programs draw on AISC 207 (Standard for Steel Building Structures) and reference AWS D1.1 as the technical welding standard. The audit evaluates whether your quality management system ensures that:
- All production welding is performed to a current, controlled WPS
- Each WPS is supported by a PQR (or is properly documented as prequalified under AWS D1.1 Clause 5)
- Welders are currently qualified for the process, position, and material they are performing in production
- Qualified inspection personnel are involved in pre-weld, in-process, and final weld inspection
- Records of the above are maintained and retrievable
The technical requirements come from D1.1. AISC certification asks whether your shop has a system that reliably meets those technical requirements on every job — not just the good ones.
Common Finding #1: Incomplete Prequalified WPS
AWS D1.1 Clause 5 prequalified WPS requirements are frequently misunderstood as simply "no testing required." The other half of that provision is that the WPS must be fully documented — every mandatory variable filled in, within the prequalified limits, and signed by a responsible individual.
Auditors commonly find prequalified WPS with blank fields: position not stated, electrode diameter range omitted, joint geometry referenced but not drawn, or preheat requirements listed as "per AWS D1.1" with no actual temperature specified. Each blank field is either a finding or a trigger for a clarifying question. If the auditor cannot determine from the WPS alone that the procedure is prequalified and complete, the finding is written.
Fix this before the audit: pull every WPS in your active library and verify that no field is blank or carries a vague cross-reference. Every WPS should stand on its own. For a checklist of what a complete AWS D1.1 WPS must contain, see CWI WPS Review Checklist.
Common Finding #2: Missing or Outdated PQR Test Reports
For tested (non-prequalified) WPS, the auditor will ask for the PQR that supports each procedure. Two failure modes appear consistently:
Missing tensile test reports. The PQR form may record tensile strength values, but the original laboratory test report must be in the file. A PQR that summarizes lab results without attaching the original mill test report or certified test report from an accredited lab is incomplete. If the lab closed, the original was lost, or no one kept the backup, the PQR is not demonstrably valid.
Expired laboratory accreditation. Many shops use the same test lab for years without checking whether its accreditation (typically AASHTO or A2LA) covers the test methods performed and is still current. An auditor may note that the PQR references tensile tests performed under a lab accreditation scope that no longer matches or has lapsed. Requalifying a procedure because of a lab documentation gap — not a process change — is an avoidable cost.
Before your audit, contact the test lab for every existing PQR and confirm current accreditation covers the applicable ASTM test methods. Attach those accreditation certificates to the PQR file. See PQR Tensile and Bend Test Requirements Under AWS D1.1 for details on what mechanical tests must be documented.
Common Finding #3: WPS Variables Outside PQR Qualified Range
A WPS specifies ranges of essential variables. The PQR qualifies those ranges. If the WPS states a base metal thickness range or a heat input range that falls outside what the PQR test coupon actually qualifies, the WPS is not supported by its referenced PQR — even though both documents exist.
This mismatch is common when WPS documents are updated over time (new position added, heat input range expanded) without generating a new test coupon or referencing an additional PQR. The WPS looks current; the PQR is genuine; but together they do not constitute a valid qualified procedure for the claimed range.
The fix is a systematic audit of your own WPS library. For each WPS, verify that every claimed range on the WPS front sheet falls within the ranges supported by the PQR(s) it references. Pay specific attention to base metal thickness, filler metal classification, and heat input. For a walkthrough of how qualified ranges work, see WPS Qualification Range: Thickness and Position Under AWS D1.1.