A PQR is a one-time investment that supports WPSs for years — sometimes decades. Knowing exactly what forces requalification is the difference between a $50,000/year welding QA budget and a $5,000/year one. Here are the triggers under AWS D1.1:2025.
The core rule
A PQR no longer supports a WPS when any essential variable drifts outside the range qualified by that PQR. The essential variables are listed in Tables 6.6 (baseline) and 6.8 (CVN supplementary).
If the WPS stays inside the qualified envelope, the PQR is still valid. If the WPS crosses an essential variable boundary, you need new qualification for that variable.
Triggers that require new qualification
The most common:
- Filler classification change. A5.1 → A5.5 (E70XX → E80XX), or A5.18 → A5.28 (carbon steel solid wire → low-alloy). Same diameter, same brand — doesn't matter. The classification change is essential.
- F-number change. Moving across F-number groups in the same A-spec — requalify.
- Base metal group change. Group I → Group II (or to a different P-number under ASME terminology). The 2025 edition uses Table 6.9 groups.
- Current type or polarity flip. DCEP to DCEN, AC to DC, pulsed to spray transfer — requalify.
- Heat input outside the qualified band. This is the most frequently violated essential. Production crews push travel speed, heat input drops below the qualified range, the procedure is no longer supported.
- Filler diameter beyond one size. A WPS qualified for 1/8 in electrodes generally covers 3/32 in and 5/32 in. Going to 3/16 in usually requires requalification.
- Position outside what the test position qualifies. 1G qualifies 1G + 1F. 3G + 4G qualifies all positions. Check the position table in Clause 6.
Triggers under CVN (Table 6.8 supplementary)
When CVN is required, Table 6.8 adds:
- Heat input increase beyond a tighter band than Table 6.6
- Interpass temperature maximum increase beyond the qualified value
- Thickness floor (1/2 in in 2025, was 5/8 in in 2020) — the PQR's plate thickness defines the lower bound
The 2025 edition relaxed the supplementary preheat requalification trigger (Row 8) — preheat changes alone no longer force requalification under CVN-supplementary rules.
What does NOT trigger requalification
- Switching between brands of the same AWS classification (E70S-6 from Lincoln → E70S-6 from ESAB)
- Adjusting amperage / voltage / travel speed within the qualified range
- Changing welder (welders are qualified separately via WPQ)
- Changing the joint sketch label format
- Reformatting the WPS document
- Updating the code edition citation (with caveats — see below)
Edition migration
Migrating a WPS from D1.1:2020 to D1.1:2025 usually does not require requalification of the underlying PQR. The 2025 edition mostly renumbered tables and tweaked specific rows. Three things to check:
- Table 6.6 row 4 — if your prequalified WPS for GMAW or FCAW listed A5.36, that filler is no longer on the allowed list in 2025
- Table 6.6 row 7 — the electrode-to-supplemental-filler ratio threshold is now ±10%; check if your PQR's recorded ratio supports the production range
- Table 6.8 row 2(a) — minimum thickness floor changed; CVN-required work in the 1/2–5/8 in band may now have wider qualified range under 2025
In each case, the migration is a paperwork update, not a new test weld.
The economics
A new PQR is $1,500–$4,000. Avoiding unnecessary requalification by understanding which changes are essential vs nonessential saves real money. The decision tree is the same for every WPS:
- What changed?
- Is it listed as essential in Table 6.6 (or 6.8 for CVN)?
- Does the change stay inside the qualified range?
- If yes, update the WPS revision; the PQR still supports it.
- If no, you need new qualification — but only for the variable that crossed.