Prequalified WPSs cost zero in lab fees but constrain your parameter envelope. PQR-supported WPSs are unlimited but cost $1,500–$4,000 each. Here's how to choose.
The cost difference between prequalified and qualified-by-test WPSs is large enough to drive procedure decisions. A 30-WPS library that's 100% prequalified costs zero in lab fees. The same library 100% qualified by test costs $45,000–$120,000 to set up.
Most shops sit somewhere in between. Here's how to decide where.
Prequalified path
Cost: $0 in lab fees. Just engineering time to write the WPS.
Speed: Days, not weeks.
Constraints: every variable must fall inside AWS D1.1 Clause 5 limits.
Process must be SMAW, SAW, GMAW (with short-circuit restrictions), or FCAW (with electrode restrictions)
Base metal must be in Table 5.3 (Group I or II carbon steels listed)
Filler must be matched to base metal per Table 5.4
Joint detail must be from Clause 5
Position and progression must be within prequalified limits
Electrode diameter must be within position-specific limits
When it fits: structural carbon-steel work with standard joints and standard fillers. Most ordinary fab shop production.
Qualified-by-test path
Cost: $1,500–$4,000 per PQR (lab fees + witness time).
Speed: 2–4 weeks per PQR.
Constraints: essentially none, as long as you can weld a test coupon and the lab can test it.
When it fits: anything outside Clause 5. Specifically:
GTAW (not prequalified under D1.1 at all)
Non-listed base metals
Filler classifications not matched to base metal in Table 5.4
Non-Annex-B joint geometries
Production parameter ranges wider than Clause 5 allows
Project specifications that mandate qualification regardless of Clause 5
Cost breakdown of a single PQR
For a typical AWS D1.1 PQR on plate:
Welder time + base metal + filler: $200–$500
Witness inspector time: $200–$600
Lab tests (tensile + bend): $800–$1,500
CVN tests (if required): +$400–$800
Macroetch (if required): +$100–$300
Engineering time to compile PQR: $200–$500
Total: $1,500–$4,000.
That's a one-time cost. The PQR supports WPSs for the procedure's lifetime — often decades.
Decision tree
For each procedure you need:
Does Clause 5 cover it? Process, base metal, filler match, joint, position all inside the limits? → Prequalified. Done.
Does Clause 5 cover most of it but not all? → Consider qualifying by test for the gap and prequalifying for the rest. Some shops keep a single PQR per process that supports a range wider than prequalified, plus a stack of prequalified WPSs for everything inside Clause 5.
Does Clause 5 not cover it at all? (GTAW, exotic base metal, non-listed filler) → Qualified by test. Budget for one PQR.
When qualification beats prequalification on economics
Three cases where qualifying by test is actually cheaper than prequalifying:
Heavy production with tight parameter latitude. If welders need wider heat-input range than prequalified allows, qualify a wider PQR-supported WPS. The lab fee amortizes over millions of welds.
Multi-process hybrid WPSs. GTAW root + SMAW fill on small-diameter pipe. GTAW isn't prequalified; you have to qualify. While you're at it, qualify a wider range.
Future-proofing for AISC seismic work. CVN-required jobs need supplementary essentials under Table 6.8. A purpose-built PQR for AISC 341 demand-critical welds opens future bids that prequalified WPSs cannot.
The library a typical structural fab shop carries
For a fab shop doing standard structural carbon-steel work:
8–12 prequalified WPSs covering SMAW, FCAW-G, FCAW-S, SAW for the common processes × thicknesses × positions
Total library size: 15–25 WPSs, total qualification cost: $5,000–$15,000 in lab fees, all up.
FAQ
Frequently asked.
If prequalified is free, why qualify by test at all?
Because prequalification constrains your parameter envelope. If your production work uses fillers, joints, or processes that fall outside Clause 5 limits — or if you want operational latitude that prequalified ranges don't give you — qualifying by test is the only path.
What's the typical mix in a small fab shop?
Most shops have 15–30 WPSs total, with about 70–80% prequalified and 20–30% qualified by test. The qualified-by-test WPSs usually cover GTAW root passes, stainless work (D1.6), or high-strength applications outside D1.1 Clause 5 limits.
Can one PQR support both prequalified and qualified-by-test WPSs?
Yes. A PQR you qualify by test can also support prequalified WPSs that happen to be inside the PQR's qualified range. There's no rule that says a PQR-supported WPS can't also be prequalified.